| 100 Years of Terror's Top 139 Die besten Horrorfilme aller Zeiten [Best Horror Films of All Time] | 2020 | Ranked | #60 |
| 1428 Elm's Alexandria Ingham's 50 greatest horror movies of all-time | 2018 | Ranked | #14 |
| 500 Days Of Film's 31 Days Of Horror Over 31 Years Of Scary Movies! | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| 501 Must-See Movies - Horror | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Aaron Christensen's Horror 101 - The A-List of Horror Films and Monster Movies | 2007 | Unranked | — |
| Addicted to Horror Movies' The 100 Scariest Horror Films of All Time | 2015 | Ranked | #4 |
| Adelaide Now's The 50 scariest movies of all time | 2013 | Ranked | #7 |
| AFPL Journal's Sean Farrell's The 100 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #18 |
| Alan Jones' The Rough Guide to Horror Movies - 50 Horror Classics | 2005 | Unranked | — |
| Alternative Press' William Wright's 20 horror movies from the '90s that are still as scary as they were then | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| AMC Filmsite's Greatest Horror Films | | Unranked | — |
| Amy Holden Jones' Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #6 |
| Arts & Faith's Top 25 Horror Films | 2011 | Ranked | #24 |
| Aullidos' Las 100 Mejores Películas de Terror | 2009 | Ranked | #38 |
| AwardsCircuit.com's Terence Johnson's Top 100 Horror Films | 2012 | Ranked | #4 |
| AZCentral's Bill Goodykoontz's 31 days of horror - Goody's countdown of the scariest flicks ever | 2017 | Ranked | #9 |
| Benjamin Straub's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #1 |
| Between the Reel's Top 100 Horror Films | 2014 | Ranked | #4 |
| Bloody Disgusting's Best Horror Movies of All Time - 1990s | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Bloody Disgusting's Trace Thurman's The 100 Best Horror Movies Ever Made | 2018 | Ranked | #8 |
| BoardGameGeek's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2009 | Ranked | #12 |
| Boss Hunting's Chris Singh's The 40 Best Horror Movies Ever Made | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Boston.com's The top 60 scariest movies of all time | 2019 | Ranked | #16 |
| Box Office Prophet's 50 Favorite Horror Films | 2002 | Ranked | #12 |
| British Vogue's Radhika Seth's 38 Cult Horror Movies To Watch This Halloween | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Bro Bible's Shrobana Rakshit's The 27 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #9 |
| BroBible's Neil Bulson's The 50 Greatest Horror Movies Of All Time | 2014 | Ranked | #15 |
| But Why Tho's Kate Sánchez' Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #13 |
| Buzzfeed's Abid Anwar's 66 Times Horror Movies Were Beautiful As Hell | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| CBR's Maxwell Pishny's The Best Horror Movie From Every Year of The 1990s | 2026 | Unranked | — |
| CBR's Wenona' 10 Best Horror Movies Based On Books | 2022 | Ranked | #4 |
| CBS Baltimore's 100 Scariest Horror Movies | 2013 | Ranked | #23 |
| CBS News' David Morgan's 50 essential horror films for Halloween | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| CBS San Fransisco's Top 40 Scariest Films Ever Made | 2013 | Ranked | #5 |
| Charlaine Harris' Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #4 |
| Chicago Film Critics Association's 100 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2006 | Ranked | #11 |
| Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film's 50 Top Scary Films | 2005 | Ranked | #15 |
| Cine.gr's The Most Scary-Movies Ever | 2010 | Ranked | #19 |
| CinemaBlend's Jason Wiese, Brent McKnight & Nick Venable's The 30 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2021 | Ranked | #9 |
| Cinemanía's 100 mejores películas de terror de todos los tiempos | 2016 | Ranked | #58 |
| Cinephiliaque's The Ultimate Top 10 Horror Films | 2012 | Ranked | #8 |
| Cineworld Cinemas' Adam Rees' Cinema's 6 most chilling psychological horror films | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Clint Switzer's Best Horror Films of the 90's | 2014 | Ranked | #1 |
| CNN en Espanol's Las películas de terror más espantosas de todos los tiempos | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Coal Region Canary's The Best Horror Movies from the 80s and 90s | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Collider's Chris Cabin's The 50 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s | 2016 | Ranked | #1 |
| Collider's Daniel Boyer's The 25 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time, Ranked | 2025 | Ranked | #23 |
| Collider's Gaby Shedwick's The 10 Scariest Movies That Will Terrify Pretty Much Anyone | 2025 | Ranked | #6 |
| Collider's Jeremy Urquhart's The 10 Fastest-Paced Horror Movies of All Time, Ranked | 2026 | Ranked | #1 |
| Collider's Jeremy Urquhart's The 10 Greatest Horror Movies of the Last 40 Years, Ranked | 2025 | Ranked | #2 |
| Collider's Jeremy Urquhart's The 10 Most Exciting Horror Movies of All Time, Ranked | 2025 | Ranked | #5 |
| Collider's Safwan Azeem's The 10 Greatest Horror Movie Masterpieces of the '90s, Ranked | 2026 | Ranked | #2 |
| Collider's The 100 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2023 | Ranked | #16 |
| Combustible Celluloid's Essential Horror Movies | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Comic Basic's Arthur S. Poe's 30 Best Horror Movies from the 1990s You Must See | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| ComingSoon's Kylie Hemmert's The Best Horror Movies Inspired by True Events | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Complex's Best Horror Movies Every Year Since Psycho | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Complex's The 50 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #40 |
| Consequence of Sound's 100 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #38 |
| Cool Material's Mike Newman's 33 Horror Movies Every Guy Should See | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Cosmopolitan's Anna Lewis' 100+ of the best horror movies to add to your must-watch list | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| Cosmopolitan's The 57 Scariest Horror Movies You Need to Watch Right Now | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Couchpop's Top 20 Serial Killer Movies | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| CraveOnline's William Bibbiani's The 100 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s! | 2017 | Ranked | #7 |
| Creepy Catalog's Chrissy Stockton's 34 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2024 | Ranked | #11 |
| Creepy Catalog's Jim Goad's 33+ Best Cannibal Movies | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| CriterionForum Lists Project - Horror | | Ranked | #114 |
| Crooks and Liars' John Amato's Top 60 Horror Movies | 2015 | Ranked | #16 |
| Cult Labs' Community Top 100 Horror Films of All Time | 2014 | Ranked | #46 |
| Cult Movie Forums' The 100 Greatest Horror & Exploitation Films Ever! | 2007 | Ranked | #68 |
| CultNuts' Badri Acharya's 30 Horror Movies That Are So Scary, You Just Can't Watch Them Alone | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Damnationdoormat's Top 100 Horror Films | 2006 | Ranked | #66 |
| Darkweb Online's Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2002 | Ranked | #3 |
| Demotivateur's Clement P.'s 11 films d'horreur tellement effrayants que c'est impossible de les regarder tout seul! | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Dennis Alink's Top 25 Best '90s Horror Films | 2015 | Ranked | #1 |
| Dexerto's Cameron Frew's 104 best horror movies ever made | 2025 | Ranked | #47 |
| Diego Carrera's A History of Horror | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| Digital Spy's Ian Sandwell, Gabriella Geisinger & Mireia Mullor's 61 Best Horror Movies That Are Actually Good and Terrifying | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| DigitalDreamDoor's 250 Greatest Horror Movies | 2022 | Ranked | #11 |
| Dinner With Max Jenke's The 20 Best Horror Films 1989-2009 | 2009 | Ranked | #2 |
| Don Sumner's Horror Movie Freak | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| Doug Bradley's Top 10 Horror Films | 2010 | Ranked | #5 |
| Dr-Faustus' GREATEST HORROR MOVIES OF ALL TIME | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Dr. Nocturna's 2006 Horror Movie Census! | 2006 | Ranked | #43 |
| Dread Central's Doctor Gash's Top 10 Greatest Horror Movies... EVER! | 2013 | Ranked | #4 |
| Dreadit's Top 100 Horror Films, 10th Anniversary Edition | 2022 | Ranked | #10 |
| Dreadit's Top 20 Horror Movies, 1990-1999 | 2017 | Ranked | #2 |
| DREGstudios' Top 20 Horror Movies of all Time | 2012 | Ranked | #8 |
| Egokick's Top 10 Best Horror Movies | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| eldiario's Alicia Aviles Pozo & Dolores Sarto's Las 20 mejores películas de terror de la historia del cine | 2015 | Ranked | #18 |
| Elle's Adam Schubak, Madison Feller & Amy Mackelden's The 50 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| EMP Museum's 100 Horror Films to See Before You Die | | Unranked | — |
| Empire's Top 400 Horrors Results | 2012 | Ranked | #52 |
| Enfemenino's Las 101 Mejores Películas de Terror para Halloween | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Entertainment Weekly's 20 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Entertainment Weekly's Chris Nashawaty's 31 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2015 | Ranked | #4 |
| Eric Forthun's Top 10 Horror Films | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Esquire's Finlay Renwick and Tom Nicholson's The 27 Best Serial Killer Movies of All Time | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| Esquire's Josh Rosenberg's The 25 Best Psychological Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Esquire's Josh Rosenberg, Emma Carey & Bria McNeal's The 100 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Esquire's Paul Schrodt's 27 Horror Movies for People Who Don't Love Horror Movies | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Essential Horror Movies - Matinee Monsters to Cult Classics by Michael Mallory | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| European Nightmares - Horror Cinema in Europe since 1945 - Filmography | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| EW's Horror Quintessentials - The 5 best 'It Could Happen to You' movies | 2014 | Ranked | #1 |
| EW's Owen Gleiberman's 20 Top Horror Films of the Past 20 Years | 2009 | Ranked | #2 |
| Exploring Your Mind's 11 Psychological Horror Movies | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| F.X. Feeney's Ten Essential "Children of Horror" Films | 2008 | Ranked | #10 |
| Faber's [Horror author] Gabriel Bergmoser on his top horror films | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| FANGORIA Immaculate's Sydney Sweeney Shares Her 7 Favorite Horror Movies | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| FANGORIA's 300 Best Horror Movies | 2011 | Unranked | — |
| Far Out Magazine's Calum Russell's The 50 greatest horror films of all time | 2022 | Ranked | #32 |
| Feel The Films' Greatest Horror Films of All-Time | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Fiction Horizon's Hrvoje Milakovic's 50 Best Psychological Horror Movies of All Time | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| filmsactu's TOP 20 des meilleurs films d'horreur de tous les temps! | 2012 | Ranked | #19 |
| FilmWalrus' My Top 200 Favorite Horror Films | 2013 | Ranked | #4 |
| FilmZone's Top 10 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2018 | Ranked | #6 |
| Final Girl Shocktoberfest Poll | 2017 | Ranked | #27 |
| Flashy Magazine's List Of Best Top 100 Horror Movies Of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #57 |
| Flavorwire's Alison Nastasi's 50 Essential Horror Films | 2012 | Ranked | #23 |
| FLICKSIDE's Arun Kumar's 50 Greatest Horror Films Of All Time | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Floating Heads' My Top 10 Horror Films Runner-Ups | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| Fluxkompensator's Stefan_F's Die besten Horrorfilme der 90er Jahre [Best Horror Films of the 90s] | 2020 | Ranked | #4 |
| Fotogramas's Las 100 mejores películas de terror de la historia del cine buenas, recomendadas y aclamadas por la crítica (2025 | | Ranked | #29 |
| Frank Darabont's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #8 |
| Funk's House of Geekery's darknite125's Best Horror Movies of the 90's | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Gamespot's Darryn Bonthuys' and Kenneth Seward Jr.'s The 20 Best Horror Movies Of The 1990s | 2023 | Ranked | #1 |
| GamesRadar+'s Becky Darke & Louise Blain's The 30 best horror movies that will haunt you long after the credits roll | 2024 | Ranked | #5 |
| GamesRadar+'s Gem Seddon's 25 Scariest '90s Horror Movies | 2014 | Ranked | #14 |
| Gary Gerani's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2010 | Ranked | #19 |
| Gateway Film Center's Horror 101 | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Geoffrey MacNab's Top 20 Horror Films | 2005 | Ranked | #20 |
| gingersnp's The Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Glamour's Abby Gardner and Christopher Rosa's 50 Scary Movies Starring Women You Must Watch This Halloween | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Glen Mazarra's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #9 |
| Glenn of the Strip's TOP 100 HORROR MOVIES OF ALL TIME! | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Good Housekeeping's Katarina Avendano's 50 of the Best Classic Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Goomba Stomp's Ricky da Conceição's 150 Greatest Horror Films of the 20th Century | 2021 | Ranked | #13 |
| Goregirl's Favourite Horror Films of the 1990s | 2013 | Ranked | #41 |
| GotchaMovies' Top 50 Horror Movies | 2014 | Ranked | #13 |
| GQ's Gladys Lai's 42 movies that all true horror fans have watched | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Granite High World's Thomas Moslander's 10 Horror Movies for a Terrifying Halloween | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Grazia's Alessandro Alicandri's 50 film horror più belli di sempre | 2013 | Ranked | #11 |
| GreenGoblin's My top 200 horror movies | 2007 | Ranked | #23 |
| Greenroom's L'Exorciste, Suspiria, Shining… le top 5 des meilleurs films d'horreur | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| groo-8's Top 200 Horror films Ever | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Harpers Bazaar's Ella Cerón's The 25 Best Halloween Movies of All Time, Ranked | 2025 | Ranked | #19 |
| HerCampus' Elizabeth Tompkins' The 30 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #10 |
| HiConsumption's Sam Jordan's The 50 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| HitFix's Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2015 | Ranked | #31 |
| HMV's 50 Greatest Horror Movies | 2008 | Ranked | #4 |
| Hollywood.com's The 26 Best Horror Films of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #8 |
| Horror Freak News' Don Sumner's The Top 100 Best Horror Movies Ever | 2016 | Ranked | #21 |
| Horror Freak News' Matt Molgaard's The 20 Greatest Horror Movies Released in the 1990s | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| Horror Homeroom's Dawn's Top 10 Horror Films | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Horror Palace's Scariest Horror Movies | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Horror.com's The Official HDC Selection from 100+ Years of Horror Cinema | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Horror.com's The Sub-genres of Horror - A Top 100 HDC Compilation | 2008 | Unranked | — |
| HorrorMovies.ca Forum's Top 300 horror films that MUST be seen before you die | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| HorrorMovies.ca's Herner Klenthur's 20 Best Horror Movies Of the 1990's | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| HorrorMovies.ca's Poppascotch's Top 50 Horror Movies | | Ranked | #23 |
| HubPages' iwritegood's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2009 | Ranked | #29 |
| iCM Forum's Top 250 Favourite Horror Films | 2022 | Ranked | #52 |
| IGN's 100 Best Horror Movies | 2017 | Ranked | #8 |
| Image Journal's Top 25 Horror Films | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| IMDb Horror Board Favorite 201 | 2014 | Ranked | #61 |
| IndieWire's The 225 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| IndieWire's Wilson Chapman's The 100 Greatest Horror Movies of All Time | 2024 | Ranked | #76 |
| IndieWire's Wilson Chapman's The Best Cannibal Films of All Time | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Inquisitr's Carter Lee's 51 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| Inside Nova's top 10 scariest horror films revealed | 2022 | Ranked | #4 |
| Insider Monkey's Isabel Rollandi's 10 Horror Movies Based on True Stories | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| IsaacOvHeck's Top 200 Horror Movies | | Ranked | #93 |
| It's A Stampede!'s Alex Wiggan's 150 best horror movies you must watch | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| J and J Production's Top 10 Horror Movies | 2014 | Ranked | #3 |
| Jacky Who's Top 20 Horror Movies | 2010 | Ranked | #12 |
| James Marriott and Kim Newman's Horror! 333 Films to Scare You to Death | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| Jamie_Shannon's Best Horror Films | 2016 | Ranked | #17 |
| Jarvis City's 15 Best Horror Movies Of 1991 | 2017 | Ranked | #1 |
| Jarvis City's 50 Best Horror Movies Of The 1990s | 2017 | Ranked | #1 |
| Jarvis City's 50 Greatest Cannibal Movies Of All Time | 2017 | Ranked | #3 |
| Jennifer Lynch's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #9 |
| Jonathan Glendening's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #8 |
| kabel eins' Die besten Horrorfilme | | Ranked | #14 |
| khaleesi_101's Favourite Horror Movies | 2017 | Ranked | #51 |
| L'Eclaireur FNAC's Thomas Chouaniere's Les 10 meilleurs films dhorreur des années 90 [The 10 Best Horror Films of the 90s] | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Large Popcorn, No Butter's Best Scary Movies of All Time -- Of ALL Time | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Latest Movies Lists' Top 100 Horror Movies | 2012 | Ranked | #34 |
| Leigh Whannell's Top 10 | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Let's Eat Cake's Kate Santos' The 25 Best Horror Movies Of All Time, No Questions Asked | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| Letterboxd's Top 250 Horror Films | 2025 | Ranked | #3 |
| Letterboxd's Top 250 Horror Films | 2025 | Ranked | #3 |
| List25's 25 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2018 | Ranked | #17 |
| Literally, Darling's Dennis Avery's 13 (Mostly) Scary Movies To Watch With The Lights Off | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Living Daylights Pictures' Dominick Bagnato's 30 Scariest Horror Movies to Watch This Halloween | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Logan Noble's Favorite Horror Films of the 1990s | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Long Island Weekly's Frank Virga's Top 10 Horror Movies | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Love Horror's Top 10 Serial Killer Films | 2018 | Ranked | #3 |
| Maika Monroe's Five Favorite Horror Films | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Mandatory's The 50 Scariest Horror Movies Ever Made | 2013 | Ranked | #15 |
| Marcus Dunstan & Patrick Melton's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #10 |
| Marginal_Crogeny's The Top 250 Horror Films of All Time | 2016 | Ranked | #11 |
| Marie Claire's Kayleigh Roberts' The 50 Classic Horror Movies Every Scary Film Buff Must See | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| Mark H. Harris' A Timeline of the History of Hollywood Horror Movies | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Mashable's Alison Foreman's 31 essential history-making horror movies to stream this spooky season | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| Men's Health's Evan Romano's 46 Psychological Horror Movies That Will Seriously Mess With Your Head | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Men's Health's Lea Anderson, Keith Nelson and Milan Polk's The 35 Best Horror Movies of the '90s to Scare You All Night Long | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Mental Floss' Rebecca Pahle's The 20 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2018 | Ranked | #17 |
| Michael Berryman's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #2 |
| Mike Mayo's VideoHound's Horror Show - 999 Hair-Raising, Hellish, and Humorous Movies | 1998 | Unranked | — |
| Movie Forums' Top 100 Horror Films | | Ranked | #75 |
| Moviefone's Gary Susman's The 30 Best Horror Movies of the Past 30 Years | 2014 | Ranked | #1 |
| Moviefone's Jesse Schedeen's The 21 Best '90s Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #1 |
| MovieMeter's Top 300 Horror Films | 2020 | Ranked | #235 |
| Movies & Mania's Essential Horror Films | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| MSN's Dave McCoy's Top 10 Scariest Movies | 2006 | Ranked | #13 |
| MSN's The best horror films in cinema history | 2018 | Ranked | #4 |
| Murray Leeder's Horror Film - A Critical Introduction | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Museum of Pop Culture's 100 Horror Films to See Before You Die | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| My Bookish Universe' My Top 10 Favourite Horror Movies | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| New Arena's Harris Ahmadzai's Ranking The 31 Best Horror Movies For Halloween | 2018 | Ranked | #8 |
| News AKMI's Victoria Bass' Top scary horror films from the 1990s | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Nightmare Nostalgia's Patti PaulterGeist's Top Ten Horror Movies of 1991! | 2021 | Ranked | #1 |
| Nightmares in Red, White and Blue - Featured Movies | 2009 | Unranked | — |
| Nikil Rawat's 30 Horror Movies That Are So Scary You Just Can't Watch Them Alone | 2015 | Ranked | #12 |
| NME's Jack Beaumont's The 25 scariest horror films of all time | 2017 | Ranked | #12 |
| North by Northwestern's Emily Sakai's Ranking my favorite scary movies by how scary they are | 2020 | Ranked | #5 |
| Osservatori Esterni's I Migliori Film Horror 1991 - 2000 | 2011 | Ranked | #11 |
| Parade's Samuel R. Murrian's 152 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #14 |
| Paste's Jim Vorel's A Century of Terror - The 100 Best Horror Movies of the Last 100 Years | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Paste's The 100 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #11 |
| Paste's The 50 Best Serial Killer Movies of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #2 |
| Paul Harris Boardman's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #3 |
| Paul Wells' The Horror Genre - From Beelzebub to Blair Witch (Short Cuts) | 2000 | Unranked | — |
| Phoenix New Times' Heather Hoch's The 20 Scariest Horror Films of All Time | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Pinkvilla's Sejal Jakhwal's 12 best horror movies of all time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Plugman's Top 100 Horror Films | | Ranked | #5 |
| PopHorror's Curt Oglesbee's Top Ten Horror Films Of The 1990's | 2016 | Ranked | #2 |
| PopOptiq's Greg Cwik's 40 Great Horror Films for the Halloween Season | 2014 | Ranked | #9 |
| PopOptiq's Ricky da Conceição's 200 Greatest Horror Films | 2015 | Ranked | #66 |
| Psychobabble's 150 Essential Horror Movies - The Complete List | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Public.fr's Le top 10 des films d'horreur à regarder à Halloween pour avoir (vraiment) peur! | 2013 | Ranked | #6 |
| Ramsey Campbell's Stevie's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2013 | Ranked | #84 |
| Rank & File Top 250 HorrorThrillers of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #1 |
| Re93animator's Top 100 Horror Films | 2011 | Ranked | #6 |
| Reader's Digest's Kelly Kuehn's The 50 Scariest Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Reel Reviews' Frank Wilkins' Best Horror Films | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| Reel.com's Top 100 Scary Movies | 1999 | Ranked | #51 |
| ReelRundown's Don's Underrated Horror Films That Fans of the Genre Need To See | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Refinery29's Alexandra Koster and Claire Fox's The 55 Best Horror Movies To Scare Yourself Silly | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| Retrospace's 100 Greatest Horror Films of All Time | 2009 | Ranked | #55 |
| Rob Schmidt's Top 10 | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Rolling Stone's 101 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #48 |
| Rotten Tomatoes' The 200 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #28 |
| Rotten Tomatoes' The 40 Best 90s Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #1 |
| Ruggero Deodato's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #3 |
| Saturn Award for Best Horror & Thriller Film | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| Saturn Award for Best Horror & Thriller Film (All nominees) | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Screen Rant's Dalton Norman's 10 Essential Horror Films That Defined The 1990s | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Screen Rant's Dena Daw's 10 Best 90s Horror Movies | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Screen Rant's Kevin Pantoja's The Definitive '90s Horror Movie For Each Year Of The Decade | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Screen Rant's Lacey Womack & Colin McCormick's 40 Terrifying Horror Movies That Arent Paranormal | 2024 | Ranked | #32 |
| ScreenCrush's The 25 Best Horror Movies of the Last 25 Years | 2015 | Ranked | #3 |
| Sean S. Cunningham's Top 10 Horror Films | 2010 | Ranked | #7 |
| Seren's Michael Shiels' Top 5 Horror Films | 2019 | Ranked | #3 |
| Shudder's The 101 Scariest Horror Movie Moments of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #38 |
| Skraek og Raedsel's Readers' 50 Greatest Horror Movies | 2010 | Ranked | #26 |
| Sky Movies' Top 100 Horror Films | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Slant Magazine's 100 Greatest Horror Films of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #51 |
| SlashFilm's Kira Deshler's 15 Horror Movies Without Jump Scares That Still Terrify Audiences | 2026 | Unranked | — |
| SlashFilm's R. R. Fletcher's The 20 Best Psychological Horror Movies Ranked | 2026 | Ranked | #14 |
| SlashFilm's The 106 Best Horror Movies Ever | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Spanish GQ's Noel Ceballos' Las 100 mejores películas de terror de la historia | 2021 | Ranked | #33 |
| Splatter Critic's Top 113 Horror Movies | 2015 | Ranked | #25 |
| Stan Winston School of Character Art's Jeff Dixon's The Return of Halloween's Top 13 Horror Movies | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Stay at Home Mum's Jody Allen's 50 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time | 2017 | Ranked | #30 |
| Steven Jay Schneider's 101 Horror Movies You Must See Before You Die | 2007 | Unranked | — |
| Studio Binder's Mike Bedard's 100 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2020 | Ranked | #11 |
| Stuff's James Croot's The ten best intelligent horror films | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| SundanceTV's Tim Dirks' Top 10 Must-See Horror Movies of the Last 25 Years | 2015 | Ranked | #9 |
| SuperAficionado.com's David Alday's Las 107 mejores películas de terror de la historia | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| SYFY WIRE's Matthew Jackson's The best horror movies of all time | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| SYFY WIRE's Will Leitch & Tim Grierson's Best '90s horror movies | 2019 | Ranked | #1 |
| Sélection du Reader's Digest's Nadine Descheneaux's 31 films d'horreur à voir absolument | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Taschen's Jonathan Penner and Paul Duncan's Horror Cinema Top 50 Horror Movies | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Taste of Cinema's Christian Olson's 15 Best Cannibal Movies of All Time | 2016 | Ranked | #3 |
| Taste of Cinema's Jake Walters' The 20 Best Horror Films Made By Non-Horror Directors | 2014 | Ranked | #11 |
| Taste of Cinema's James Swift's The 30 Best Horror Movies of The 1990s | 2017 | Ranked | #2 |
| Taste of Cinema's Tessa Williams' The 21 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s | 2015 | Ranked | #1 |
| Technique's Yesha Thakkar's The top 5 scary films to kick off Halloween | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Teen Vogue's The 85 Best Scary Movies Every Horror and Suspense Fan Should See | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Tell Tales' Maria Supplisson's 25 Best Horror Movies to Traumatize You | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Terry L. Vinson's The 25 Best Horror Films of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #8 |
| The Advocate's 16 Horror Films Only LGBTQ People Truly Understand | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| The Astounding B Monster - Kevin Clement's horror top ten | 2014 | Ranked | #8 |
| The Atlantic's Kevin Fallon's The Greatest Horror Films of the Past 51 Years | 2011 | Ranked | #4 |
| The Bedrock Blog's The Cutting Room Floor | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| The Columbus Dispatch's Rafer Guzman's The 20 scariest horror movies of all time | 2019 | Ranked | #6 |
| The Daily Dot's John-Michael Bond's The 10 scariest movies of all time | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| The Essential Films' 100 Essential Horror Films | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw's Scariest horror films ever | 2018 | Ranked | #10 |
| The Hollywood Reporter's Richard Newby's The Best 90s Horror Movies | 2025 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Hollywood Verdict's Top 10 Best Horror Movies | 2020 | Ranked | #10 |
| The Horror Syndicate's Top 100 Horror Movies Fan Vote 2019 | 2019 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Independent's Derek O'Connor's The ten scariest movies ever made | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| The New Yorker's The Five Scariest Movies Ever | 2008 | Ranked | #2 |
| The Orlok's Top 5 of 1991 | 2015 | Ranked | #1 |
| The Pioneer Woman's Erin Cavoto & Nora Knoepflmacher's 40 Best Scary Halloween Movies That Will Give You Nightmares All October | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| The Playlist's The 30 Best Horror Films Of The 1990s | 2015 | Ranked | #2 |
| The Ringer's Horror Oscars - The Best Scary Movies of Every Year Since 1978 | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| The Salt Lake Tribune's Sean P. Means' 10 frightening films for a Halloween horror fix | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| The Scariest Thing's The Top 500 Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #24 |
| The Scariest Things' Chris Ralph's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #18 |
| The Scariest Things' Deena Warner's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #13 |
| The Scariest Things' Elizabeth Williams' Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #7 |
| The Scariest Things' Joe Moe's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Scariest Things' Marne Oyen's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #19 |
| The Scariest Things' Mike Fryer's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Scariest Things' Roberta Pennington's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Scariest Things' Tom Carter's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #8 |
| The Times' The best horror films ever made Top 40 ranked | 2023 | Ranked | #12 |
| The Vault of Horror's Top 25 Horror Films of the Modern Era | 2008 | Ranked | #3 |
| The Wandering Image's TOP 70 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 90s | 2012 | Ranked | #2 |
| TheHorrorSyndicate.com's Rayzor's Top 50 Horror Films of the 1990s | 2025 | Ranked | #1 |
| Thrillist's Scott Weinberg's The 75 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #63 |
| Time Out's The 100 best horror movies of all time | 2026 | Ranked | #44 |
| Time's Megan McCluskey's The 15 Best Religious Horror Movies | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| TMA's 25 Greatest Horror Movies of All Time | 2010 | Ranked | #6 |
| Too Scary To Watch's Best 90's Horror Films | 2011 | Unranked | — |
| Top 10 Horror Films of the 1990s by John Kenneth Muir | 2011 | Ranked | #2 |
| Top 200 Movies' Top 50 Best Horror Movies | | Ranked | #8 |
| TOP 666 HORROR MOVIES (Freaky Fuckin Friday) | 2014 | Ranked | #38 |
| Topito's Top 15 des films les plus flippants de l'histoire du cinéma | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Total Sci-Fi's The 100 Greatest Horror Movies | 2009 | Ranked | #24 |
| Town & Country's Annie Goldsmith's 20 All-Time Best Horror Movies | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| Trinikid's Moumita Basu's List Of 20 Of The Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| UK Mix Top 100 Horror Films | 2011 | Ranked | #19 |
| Ultimate Classic Rock's Michael Gallucci's The Best Horror Movie From Every Year - 1920-2022 | 2023 | Unranked | — |
| UNILAD's Cameron Frew's UNILAD's Top 50 Horror Films Of All Time | 2020 | Ranked | #29 |
| Urbo's Jamie Wiles' The Top 50 Horror Movies Of All Time | 2018 | Ranked | #12 |
| Utica Public Library's 30 Classic Horror Films Of The 20th Century | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Vanity Fair's Les 50 films d'horreur à voir absolument | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Vanity Fair's Matthew Jacobs' The 32 Best Horror Movies to Keep You Up at Night | 2022 | Ranked | #3 |
| Variety's 100 best horror films of all time | 2024 | Ranked | #13 |
| VIRUS' Creepy ClasSICKs Vol. 1 | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Vogue.fr's Manon Garrigues' Les 15 meilleurs films d'horreur de tous les temps [The 15 best horror films of all time] | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Vulture's Angelica Jade Bastién's The 30 Best Female-Led Horror Films of All Time | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Vulture's Brooke Knisley's 11 Valentine's Day Horror Movies to Watch When You're Horrified by Valentine's Day | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Vulture's David Edelstein and Bilge Ebiri's The 25 Best Horror Movies Since The Shining | 2013 | Ranked | #2 |
| Vulture's Jordan Crucchiola's 55 Essential Queer Horror Films | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Vulture's Jordan Crucchiola's The 100 Scares That Shaped Horror | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| WatchMojo's Top 10 Horror Movies of the 1990s | | Ranked | #1 |
| We Got This Covered's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2013 | Ranked | #19 |
| WhatCulture's 100 Greatest Horror Movies Of All Time | 2018 | Ranked | #13 |
| WhatCulture's David Braga's 50 Most Essential Horror Movies Of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #6 |
| WhatCulture's Ian Watson's 20 Scariest Horror Movies Of All Time | 2015 | Ranked | #7 |
| WhatCulture's Kieran Hair's 12 Incredible Horror Movies With No Jump Scares | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| WILDSound Movies' Top 100 Horror Movies | 2011 | Ranked | #68 |
| WIRED's The best horror movies everyone should watch at least once | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Yam Laranas's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #10 |
| Yardbarker's Asher Luberto 25 horror movies that are great to watch any time | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Yardbarker's Matt Sulem's 25 horror movies that were based on true stories | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| You Wanna See Something Really Scary A 365 Day Guide to Must See Horror Films by W.P. Spence | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| You're Gonna Need a Bigger Blog's Top 10 Horror Movies | 2014 | Ranked | #3 |
| YouGov's Scariest Horror Movies Survey | 2015 | Ranked | #11 |
| Zimbio's Joe Robberson's The Top 11 Scariest Movies Ever Made | 2015 | Ranked | #5 |
| Zombies Don't Run's Chuck Conry's Top 10 Horror Movies Of The 90's | 2010 | Ranked | #9 |