| 365 Horror Movie's Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2011 | Ranked | #103 |
| Aaron Christensen's Horror 101 - The A-List of Horror Films and Monster Movies | 2007 | Unranked | — |
| Addicted to Horror Movies' The 10 Best Horror Movies from 1990 | 2017 | Ranked | #2 |
| Alex Orr's Top 10 | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Alternative Press' William Wright's 20 horror movies from the '90s that are still as scary as they were then | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| AMC Filmsite's Greatest Horror Films | | Unranked | — |
| Andrés Muschietti's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #10 |
| Arrow in the Head's Jake Dee's Top 10 War-Set Horror Flicks! | 2014 | Ranked | #1 |
| Between the Reel's Top 100 Horror Films | 2014 | Ranked | #12 |
| Blood and Guts for Grown Ups' 10 Awesome 90's Horror Movies | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Bloody Disgusting's Best Horror Movies of All Time - 1990s | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Bloody Disgusting's Trace Thurman's The 100 Best Horror Movies Ever Made | 2018 | Ranked | #92 |
| Box Office Prophet's 50 Favorite Horror Films | 2002 | Ranked | #39 |
| CBS Baltimore's 100 Scariest Horror Movies | 2013 | Ranked | #67 |
| CBS San Fransisco's Top 40 Scariest Films Ever Made | 2013 | Ranked | #29 |
| Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film's 50 Top Scary Films | 2005 | Ranked | #25 |
| Collider's Chris Cabin's The 50 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s | 2016 | Ranked | #12 |
| Collider's Haleigh Foutch's 9 Psychological Horror Movies That Will Seriously Mess with Your Head | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Collider's S. K. Sapiano's The 10 Best Arthouse Horror Movies | 2024 | Ranked | #5 |
| Collider's Safwan Azeem's The 10 Greatest Horror Movie Masterpieces of the '90s, Ranked | 2026 | Ranked | #1 |
| Collider's The 100 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2023 | Ranked | #82 |
| Combustible Celluloid's Essential Horror Movies | 2024 | Unranked | — |
| Comic Basic's Arthur S. Poe's 30 Best Horror Movies from the 1990s You Must See | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Comics Bulletin's Top Ten Horror Films 1990s | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| ComingSoon's Max Evry's The 10 Best Horror Movies | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| ComingSoon's Ryan Turek's 20 Movies That Prove '90s Horror Wasn't So Bad | 2014 | Ranked | #2 |
| CraveOnline's William Bibbiani's The 100 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s! | 2017 | Ranked | #3 |
| CriterionForum Lists Project - Horror | | Ranked | #165 |
| Cult Labs Forum's Best Horror Films Year by Year | | Unranked | — |
| Cult Labs' Community Top 100 Horror Films of All Time | 2014 | Ranked | #42 |
| Cultured Vultures' Gabriel Ricard's 10 Best Body Horror Movies To Squirm Your Way Through | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Cultured Vultures' Mark LoProto's 20 Best Cosmic Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #3 |
| Damnationdoormat's Top 100 Horror Films | 2006 | Ranked | #91 |
| Darkweb Online's Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2002 | Ranked | #96 |
| David Morrigan's Best Religious Horror Movies | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Dazed's Zing Tsjeng's Top ten medical horror films | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Den of Geek's Ryan Lambie's The Underrated Horror Movies of the 1990s | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Derek Vinyard's Top 75 Horror movies | 2014 | Ranked | #25 |
| Details' Calum Marsh's The 10 Best Horror Films You Haven't Seen Yet | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| DigitalDreamDoor's 250 Greatest Horror Movies | 2022 | Ranked | #105 |
| Dinner With Max Jenke's The 20 Best Horror Films 1989-2009 | 2009 | Ranked | #14 |
| DiskuterFilms' Top 50 Horror Films | 2010 | Ranked | #35 |
| Dr-Faustus' GREATEST HORROR MOVIES OF ALL TIME | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| Dreadit's Top 100 Horror Films, 10th Anniversary Edition | 2022 | Ranked | #73 |
| Dreadit's Top 20 Horror Movies, 1990-1999 | 2017 | Ranked | #12 |
| Dreadit's Top Lovecraftian Horror | 2021 | Ranked | #22 |
| DREGstudios' Top 20 Horror Movies of all Time | 2012 | Ranked | #14 |
| Empire's Top 400 Horrors Results | 2012 | Ranked | #303 |
| Eric Ian Steele's The Best Horror Movies of the Past 50 years! Part 4! The Nineties! | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Esquire's Paul Schrodt's 27 Horror Movies for People Who Don't Love Horror Movies | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| FANGORIA's 300 Best Horror Movies | 2011 | Unranked | — |
| Film.com's The Top 50 Horror Movies of All Time | 2012 | Ranked | #22 |
| FilmschoolWTF's Top 100 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2014 | Ranked | #68 |
| Flashy Magazine's List Of Best Top 100 Horror Movies Of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #72 |
| Fluxkompensator's Stefan_F's Die besten Horrorfilme der 90er Jahre [Best Horror Films of the 90s] | 2020 | Ranked | #1 |
| Fotogramas's Las 100 mejores películas de terror de la historia del cine buenas, recomendadas y aclamadas por la crítica (2025 | | Ranked | #55 |
| Funk's House of Geekery's darknite125's Best Horror Movies of the 90's | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| GamesRadar+'s Gem Seddon's 25 Scariest '90s Horror Movies | 2014 | Ranked | #25 |
| GamesRadar+'s Josh Winning's 50 Greatest Indie Horror Films | 2012 | Ranked | #31 |
| Gateway Film Center's Horror 101 | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Goregirl's 100 Favourite Horror Films of All Time | 2009 | Ranked | #65 |
| Goregirl's Favourite Horror Films of the 1990s | 2013 | Ranked | #2 |
| GreenGoblin's My top 200 horror movies | 2007 | Ranked | #94 |
| Gunnar Hansen's Top 10 Horror Films | 2010 | Ranked | #5 |
| HiConsumption's Sam Jordan's The 50 Best Horror Movies Of All Time | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| HitFix's Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time | 2015 | Ranked | #100 |
| Hollie Horror's 1990-1999 | 2021 | Ranked | #49 |
| Horror Freak News' Matt Molgaard's The 20 Greatest Horror Movies Released in the 1990s | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| Horror Homeroom's Lev A. Nikulin's Eight Medical Horror Films (and Two Shorts) to Watch in Quarantine | 2021 | Unranked | — |
| Horror.com's The Official HDC Selection from 100+ Years of Horror Cinema | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Horror.com's The Sub-genres of Horror - A Top 100 HDC Compilation | 2008 | Unranked | — |
| HorrorMovies.ca Forum's Top 300 horror films that MUST be seen before you die | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| HorrorNews.net's Adrian Halen's Top 25 Weirdest Horror Movies I've Ever Seen | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Howard Ford's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #6 |
| HubPages' iwritegood's Top 100 Horror Movies | 2009 | Ranked | #63 |
| iCM Forum's Top 250 Favourite Horror Films | 2022 | Ranked | #184 |
| IGN's 100 Best Horror Movies | 2017 | Ranked | #30 |
| IMDb Horror Board Favorite 201 | 2014 | Ranked | #65 |
| IndieWire's The 225 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Inquisitr's Carter Lee's 51 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2016 | Unranked | — |
| io9's Meredith Woerner's 50 Scariest Movies Of All Time | 2011 | Ranked | #21 |
| IsaacOvHeck's Top 200 Horror Movies | | Ranked | #108 |
| James Marriott and Kim Newman's Horror! 333 Films to Scare You to Death | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| Jarvis City's 50 Best Horror Movies Of The 1990s | 2017 | Ranked | #15 |
| JarvisCity's 15 Best Horror Movies Of 1990 | 2017 | Ranked | #2 |
| John Penney's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #3 |
| L'Eclaireur FNAC's Thomas Chouaniere's Les 10 meilleurs films dhorreur des années 90 [The 10 Best Horror Films of the 90s] | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| Letterboxd's Top 250 Horror Films | 2025 | Ranked | #93 |
| Letterboxd's Top 250 Horror Films | 2025 | Ranked | #97 |
| Listverse's Elizabeth Kelly's Top 10 Great Lesser Known Horrors | 2010 | Ranked | #6 |
| LitReactor's Christopher Shultz's Ten More Well-Written Horror Films | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Live Science's Benjamin Radford's Top 10 Scariest Movies Ever | 2008 | Unranked | — |
| Love Horror's Top 10 Psychological Horror Films | 2018 | Ranked | #3 |
| Marginal_Crogeny's The Top 250 Horror Films of All Time | 2016 | Ranked | #77 |
| Mark Alan Miller's Top 10 | 2015 | Ranked | #4 |
| MensXP's Shantanu Prasher's 10 Lesser Known Horror Movies That Will Scare The Life Out Of You | 2015 | Ranked | #2 |
| Metro News' Adam Boult's The 100 Best Horror Films | 2015 | Unranked | — |
| Mike Mayo's VideoHound's Horror Show - 999 Hair-Raising, Hellish, and Humorous Movies | 1998 | Unranked | — |
| Moviefone's Jesse Schedeen's The 21 Best '90s Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #8 |
| MovieMeditation's His Top 50 Favorite Horror Films | 2015 | Ranked | #23 |
| Movieweb's Rudransh Bundela & Federico Furzan's The 20 Best Slow-Burn Horror Movies of All Time | 2024 | Ranked | #20 |
| Nerd Lists and Horror Movies' Steve Holland's 100 Favorite Horror Films | 2012 | Ranked | #7 |
| News AKMI's Victoria Bass' Top scary horror films from the 1990s | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| OH THE HORROR! - Must see horror movies | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Otto's Movies' Ultimate Top 500 Horror Movies | | Ranked | #199 |
| Paper Street Cinema's Greg Douglass' Top 50 Best Horror Movies | 2009 | Ranked | #12 |
| Parade's Samuel R. Murrian's 152 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2025 | Ranked | #37 |
| Paste's Jim Vorel's A Century of Terror - The 100 Best Horror Movies of the Last 100 Years - Honorable mentions | 2019 | Unranked | — |
| Playbuzz's iLLUViTiZZLE's The 9 Best Psychological Horror Movies Of All Time | 2017 | Unranked | — |
| Plugman's Top 100 Horror Films | | Ranked | #14 |
| PopHorror's Curt Oglesbee's Top Ten Horror Films Of The 1990's | 2016 | Ranked | #7 |
| Rage of Rayzor's Top 100 Horror Films | 2015 | Ranked | #34 |
| Re93animator's Top 100 Horror Films | 2011 | Ranked | #123 |
| Reel World Matters' My Top 20 Horror Films Of The Last 20 Years | 2009 | Unranked | — |
| Rotten Tomatoes' The 200 Best Horror Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #196 |
| Rotten Tomatoes' The 40 Best 90s Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #19 |
| Rue Morgue's 200 Alternative Horror Films | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| ScoopWhoop's Rohit Bhattacharya's 15 Psychological Horror Movies That'll Really Fuck With Your Minds | 2020 | Unranked | — |
| Screen Rant's Colin McCormick's The 15 Best Psychological Horror Movies That Will Mess With Your Brain | 2021 | Ranked | #7 |
| Screen Rant's Lacey Womack & Colin McCormick's 40 Terrifying Horror Movies That Arent Paranormal | 2024 | Ranked | #27 |
| Screen Rant's Megan Summers' 10 Excellent Horror Movies About War | 2020 | Ranked | #10 |
| Shudder's The 101 Scariest Horror Movie Moments of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #56 |
| Skraeg og Raedsel's 50 Greatest Horror Movies | 2010 | Ranked | #49 |
| Sky Movies' Top 100 Horror Films | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| SlashFilm's Margaret David's The 10 Best Religious Horror Movies You Need To Check Out | 2025 | Unranked | — |
| SlashFilm's Margaret David's The 22 Best Lovecraftian Movies Of All Time | 2026 | Unranked | — |
| Stan Winston School of Character Art's Jeff Dixon's The Return of Halloween's Top 13 Horror Movies | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Stay at Home Mum's Jody Allen's 50 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time | 2017 | Ranked | #21 |
| Stephen Wagner's Top 10 Scariest Movies | | Unranked | — |
| Steven Jay Schneider's 101 Horror Movies You Must See Before You Die | 2007 | Unranked | — |
| SundanceTV's Tim Dirks' Top 10 Must-See Horror Movies of the Last 25 Years | 2015 | Ranked | #3 |
| Taste of Cinema's Bryn Tilly's 25 Modern Horror Films That Are Genuinely Nightmarish | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Taste of Cinema's Mansur Zeynalov's 14 Great 1990s Horror Movie Classics You May Have Missed | 2018 | Ranked | #4 |
| Taste of Cinema's Tessa Williams' The 21 Best Horror Movies of the 1990s | 2015 | Ranked | #6 |
| Teen Vogue's The 85 Best Scary Movies Every Horror and Suspense Fan Should See | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| The Bedrock Blog's The Cutting Room Floor | 2010 | Unranked | — |
| The Essential Films' 100 Essential Horror Films | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| The Ghost Diaries' Jamie Naqvi's The Ten Greatest Horror Films Of All Time | 2013 | Ranked | #4 |
| The Horror Syndicate's Top 100 Horror Movies of All-Time | 2017 | Ranked | #68 |
| The Independent's Derek O'Connor's The ten scariest movies ever made | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| The Lineup's Orrin Grey & DeAnna Janes 32 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time | 2019 | Ranked | #21 |
| The Orlok's Top 5 of 1990 | 2015 | Ranked | #1 |
| The Playlist's The 30 Best Horror Films Of The 1990s | 2015 | Ranked | #13 |
| The Scariest Thing's The Top 500 Horror Movies of All Time | 2022 | Ranked | #329 |
| The Scariest Things' Tom Carter's Top 25 Horror Movies | 2018 | Ranked | #17 |
| The Vault of Horror's Top 25 Horror Films of the Modern Era | 2008 | Ranked | #28 |
| The Wandering Image's TOP 70 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 90s | 2012 | Ranked | #1 |
| TheHorrorSyndicate.com's Rayzor's Top 50 Horror Films of the 1990s | 2025 | Ranked | #35 |
| Thickstache's Brian McAsey's The Ten Best Horror Films You've Never Seen | 2009 | Unranked | — |
| Thought Catalog's Rob Fee's The Best Horror Movie Of The Year For The Last 40 Years | 2014 | Unranked | — |
| Time Out's The 100 best horror movies of all time | 2026 | Ranked | #39 |
| Today's Sarah Lemire's 68 of the scariest horror movies of all time | 2022 | Unranked | — |
| Too Scary To Watch's Best 90's Horror Films | 2011 | Unranked | — |
| TOP 666 HORROR MOVIES (Freaky Fuckin Friday) | 2014 | Ranked | #230 |
| Unreality's Remy Carreiro's Six Visually Experimental Horror Films | 2012 | Unranked | — |
| Vulture's Jordan Crucchiola's The 100 Scares That Shaped Horror | 2018 | Unranked | — |
| W-Cinema's J Luis Rivera's Top 15 Overlooked Horror Films for this Halloween | 2007 | Ranked | #9 |
| WhatCulture's Sean Ferrick's 10 Best Horror Movies Turning 30 In 2020 [Best Horror Movies of 1990] | 2020 | Ranked | #9 |
| Yam Laranas's Top 10 | 2012 | Ranked | #6 |
| You Wanna See Something Really Scary A 365 Day Guide to Must See Horror Films by W.P. Spence | 2013 | Unranked | — |
| Zack Snyder's Top 10 Horror Films | 2010 | Ranked | #6 |